Ex Parte NOGUERA-RODRIGUEZ et al - Page 7




          Appeal No. 2002-2292                                                        
          Application No. 09/139,749                                                  


               While we agree that instant claim 1 does not explicitly                
          state that all control of signaling functions is relinquished by            
          one radio network controller when transferring destination                  
          address and binding information, it is only reasonable to                   
          interpret the claim as so relinquishing such control.  Claim 1              
          recites “releasing a number of transport level connections” and             
          “establishing a new transport level connection between the second           
          radio network controller and each of a plurality of destination             
          nodes...”  It is true that Muszynski releases resources employed            
          in a diversity leg, but, in the absence of evidence to the                  
          contrary, we agree with appellants that “the release of a                   
          diversity leg is not equivalent to disclosing the release of a              
          transport level connection, nor does the release of a transport             
          level connection necessarily flow from the release of a diversity           
          leg” [reply brief-page 4].                                                  
               As explained by appellants, at page 4 of the reply brief,              
          and supported by the instant specification, at the top of page 3,           
          “a diversity leg represents a logical connection between two end            
          points, whereas a corresponding transport level connection is a             
          functional layer within a layered network architecture design               
          that is responsible for conveying the signals associated with the           
          network diversity leg.”  Our decision herein is based on this               

                                         -7-                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007