Ex Parte WOLFE et al - Page 5




             Appeal No. 2003-0094                                                              Page 5                
             Application No. 08/995,786                                                                              


             turbine 4 that is motivated by compressed air, and a compressor 2 that is driven by the                 
             turbines and provides a first stream of air to the combustion chamber and a second                      
             stream of air through a cooler and then to the second turbine.  The air exhausted from                  
             the second turbine flows to the space to be cooled.  With regard to the requirements of                 
             claim 21, Singleton fails to disclose or teach a fuel cell and the compressor supplying a               
             stream of compressed gas to an oxidant inlet of the fuel cell.                                          
                    Wolfe is directed to an apparatus for powering an electric motor to propel a                     
             vehicle and comprises “a control mechanism and a fuel cell for providing electric power                 
             directly to the electric motor” (column 3, lines 18-20).  As shown in Figure 5, which is                
             the embodiment to which the examiner has referred, a compressor 98 and an electric                      
             generator 100 are mounted on a shaft that is rotated by a turbine 104.  The compressor                  
             supplies compressed air to a fuel cell 80.  As explained in lines 30-46 of column 8,                    
             “[t]he generator electric power output 102 . . . supplements the fuel cell electric power               
             output 96 . . . [and] is added to the fuel cell output voltage in order to produce power for            
             the electric motor.”  In order to provide start-up and control flexibility, a combustor 125             
             is provided which receives the exhaust gases from the fuel cell along with additional                   
             fuel and “completes the reaction” of partially-reacted fuel and oxidizer streams from the               
             fuel cell to boost the inlet temperature to the turbine (column 10, lines 39-44).                       
                    The examiner proposes to add a fuel cell to the Singleton system “upstream of                    
             the combustor 126” because a fuel cell would provide the advantages of “lower                           








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007