Ex Parte BOLES et al - Page 7




          Appeal No. 2003-0194                                                        
          Application No. 09/280,112                                                  


          references, nor has the examiner convincingly pointed to anything           
          in these references, showing a bank select unit for selecting a             
          bank wherein the selected bank “forms a register file” (as in               
          instant claim 2).  Since there is no register file, there can be            
          no “arithmetic logic unit coupled with said register file.”                 
          Further, the mapping described in Lau (where a memory controller            
          “maps” all of the memory locations in a virtual memory bank to a            
          first area on a memory map) does not appear to be the mapping               
          claimed, i.e., “a plurality of special function registers being             
          mapped to one of said banks in said data memory, wherein one of             
          said special function registers is a working register being                 
          coupled with said arithmetic logic unit” (claim 2).                         
               With regard to the “working register,” the examiner relies             
          on element 401 of Noguchi.  We do not regard this element as a              
          “working register,” as set forth in instant claims 1 and 2,                 
          because no “special function” (claim 2) or mapping of this                  
          “working register” in a data memory (claim 1) has been shown by             
          the examiner.  To the extent the examiner relies on Lau, as                 
          explained supra, there would have been no reason to modify any              
          register in Noguchi in order to arrive at the claimed “working              
          register.”                                                                  
               With regard to the claimed “bank select unit,” the examiner            

                                         -7–                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007