Ex Parte Fader et al - Page 6




              Appeal No. 2003-0292                                                                 Page 6                
              Application No. 09/584,032                                                                                 


              the reservoir 24.  The air gun may be a conventional sand blasting gun; however, Louis                     
              teaches that for a clear understanding of his invention it should be appreciated that in                   
              the conventional use of such apparatus the abrasive action of the missile particles                        
              remove material from the target surface whereas in the practice of his invention just the                  
              opposite and hence unobvious result is obtained wherein the target surface is coated.                      
              For  large scale production, Louis teaches that conventional shot peening equipment will                   
              be found very useful.                                                                                      


                     In example 7, steel balls were coated with finely divided metallic silver and                       
              impacted against a piece of glass. In example 8,  steel balls were coated with finely                      
              divided metallic lead and impacted against a piece of glass.                                               


              Babecki                                                                                                    
                     Babecki's invention relates to the metal plating of substrates such as metal                        
              substrates.  More particularly, his invention is directed to the deposition of metallic                    
              coatings on other substrates by peening metallic powder onto the surface of the                            
              substrates.  Babecki teaches (abstract, lines 6-9) that his process has as one of its                      
              advantages providing mechanical working (hardening) of the surface simultaneously                          
              with the metal plating.                                                                                    









Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007