Ex Parte FERGUSON et al - Page 7





          Appeal No. 2003-0360                                                        
          Application No. 08/947,032                                                  


               The examiner uses the example of a date as an attribute in             
          Blandford, but Blandford does not use the date of the diary entry           
          as an “archiving condition” to determine whether the document is            
          to be archived nor is there any electronic analysis of the date             
          of the diary entry to determine if the date (attribute) satisfies           
          an archiving condition.                                                     
               Still further, the examiner asserts that it would have been            
          obvious to have a skilled programmer compose “formulas” for                 
          relative reference dates for archiving the document but we think            
          appellants make a good point when they urge that                            
               . . .there would be no need to modify Blandford                        
               in order to have “skilled programmers compose                          
               formulae for relative reference dates for                              
               archiving the document” as suggested by the                            
               Office Action. Furthermore, Blandford already                          
               discloses the ability to determine the date                            
               which a data block is created in order to prevent                      
               archiving of a data block which has allegedly                          
               been created prior to a previously stored data                         
               block.  This feature in Blandford prevents                             
               modifications or the addition of diary entries                         
               after the fact. . . (principal brief-page 6).                          
               Blandford discloses an electronic diary wherein diary                  
          entries are archived in such a manner that modification of those            
          entries can be identified and removed or restored to recreate the           
          corresponding original entries.  Other than “archiving”                     


                                   -7-                                                





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007