Ex Parte CARROLL et al - Page 4


          Appeal No. 2003-0577                                                        
          Application No. 09/194,378                                                  

          (c) are typically present in the composition in amounts ranging             
          from 25 to 90% by weight, 10-70% by weight, and 0.1 to 15% by               
          weight, respectively.  (Page 3, lines 18-20; page 5, lines 5-6;             
          page 6, lines 4-6.)  Cardinal explains the characteristics of               
          the thermoplastic composition as follows (page 1, lines 3-18):              
                    This invention relates to a thermoplastic                         
               composition and its use in preparing films                             
               demonstrating moisture vapor, oxygen and carbon                        
               dioxide permeability, while acting as barriers to                      
               liquids and microorganisms such as viruses and                         
               bacteria.  Such films are found in various articles                    
               including wound coverings, transdermal patches,                        
               operating room drapes, protective clothing, diapers,                   
               personal hygiene products (feminine hygiene,                           
               incontinency), waterproof and outdoor clothing                         
               articles, food packaging such as for fresh vegetables,                 
               fruit, cheese and meat, films used in plant growing                    
               environments and any end-use where it is desirable to                  
               combine “breathability” and liquid barrier properties                  
               to liquids and microorganisms.                                         
                    Films made from the inventive compositions also                   
               demonstrate good adhesion to substrates made from                      
               materials containing certain functional groups that                    
               react with the “reactive groups” described                             
               hereinafter.  Such substrates include melamine.                        
               [underscoring added.]                                                  
               Unlike Cardinal, Brown teaches a protective cover for                  
          vehicles and equipment made from conjugate fiber nonwoven fabric            
          having a basis weight between about 1 and 8 osy laminated with a            
          film, such as an ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer, polyvinyl                
          chloride, polyamide, or polyolefin film.  (Column 1, lines 16-17            
          and 40-43; column 6, lines 46-51; column 8, lines 62-65.)                   
          According to Brown, “[t]he conjugate fibers may be in a                     

                                          4                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007