Ex Parte Laver et al - Page 2


          Appeal No. 2003-0819                                                        
          Application No. 09/872,928                                                  

               The subject matter on appeal relates to: (i) a heat-curable            
          powder coating composition (claims 14-17 and 19-24); (ii) a                 
          process for reducing the discoloration of heat-cured powder                 
          coating compositions (claim 25-28); and (iii) a heat-cured film             
          (claims 29 and 30).  Further details of this appealed subject               
          matter are recited in representative claims 14 and 25 reproduced            
          below:                                                                      
                    14.  A heat-curable powder coating composition                    
               comprising                                                             
                    a) an epoxy resin, a polyester-hydroxyalkylamide,                 
               a polyester-glycoluril, an epoxy-polyester resin, a                    
               polyester-triglycidyl isocyanurate, a hydroxy-                         
               functional polyester-blocked polyisocyanate, a                         
               hydroxy-functional polyester-uretdione, an acrylate                    
               resin with hardener or a mixture of such resins,                       
                    b) as stabilizer at least one compound of the                     
               formula V                                                              

                               O                                                      
                         O                                                            
                                          R9                                          
                                 H                                                    
                    R2                          R10                                   

                    R3        R5                                                      
                                                R11                                   
                                      R7                                              
                         R4                                                           
                                           R8                    (V)                  
               in which                                                               
                                                                                     
          Zeren (paper 9).  The examiner indicated that the amendment will            
          be entered for purposes of this appeal.  (Advisory action mailed            
          Jul. 19, 2002.)  As to the Zeren declaration, the examiner                  
          appears to have entered this evidence as well.  (Examiner’s                 
          answer mailed Dec. 12, 2002, paper 15, p. 6).                               
                                                                                     

                                          2                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007