Ex Parte Noble et al - Page 8

                  Appeal No. 2003-0824                                                           Page 8                    
                  Application No. 09/713,974                                                                               

                                                        Summary                                                            
                         The references cited by the examiner do not support a prima facie case of                         
                  obviousness.  The rejections under 35 U.S.C. § 103 are reversed.                                         


                                                      REVERSED                                                             



                                       WILLIAM F. SMITH                    )                                               
                                       Administrative Patent Judge         )                                               
                                                                           )                                               
                                                                           )                                               
                                                                           ) BOARD OF PATENT                               
                                       ERIC GRIMES                        )                                               
                                       Administrative Patent Judge         )   APPEALS AND                                 
                                                                           )                                               
                                                                           ) INTERFERENCES                                 
                                                                           )                                               
                                       LORA M. GREEN                       )                                               
                                       Administrative Patent Judge         )                                               























Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November  3, 2007