Ex Parte Balzer et al - Page 8




              Appeal No. 2003-0867                                                               Page 8                
              Application No. 09/688,104                                                                               


              Teachings of Junginger                                                                                   
                     Junginger's invention relates to a door for a vehicle and, in particular, to an                   
              upwardly folding vehicle door to selectively close, for example, a rear opening in a                     
              vehicle body.  The folding door has a lower panel that is pivotally connected to an upper                
              panel.  The lower panel pivots inwardly and upwardly toward the upper section to effect                  
              opening.                                                                                                 


                     Junginger teaches in the BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION section (column                              
              1, lines 39-49) that                                                                                     
                     most known upwardly folding doors are relatively heavy because they have inner                    
                     and outer structural panels stamped from steel that are hemmed and spot                           
                     welded along peripheral, flanged edges to form a door.  The plastic door                          
                     mentioned above reduces weight, but sacrifices durability by using a living plastic               
                     hinge.  Using plastic as a structural component reduces the overall stiffness and                 
                     strength of the door.  Thus, the conventional folding doors do not provide light                  
                     weight without sacrificing bending stiffness and impact strength.                                 


                     Junginger teaches in the SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION section (column 2,                              
              lines 8-24) that                                                                                         
                            [t]he upper and lower sections have upper and lower frames, respectively.                  
                     Each frame is preferably cast from magnesium to reduce door weight up to 40%                      
                     compared to conventional designs.  However, the present design does not                           
                     sacrifice bending stiffness and impact strength to achieve such a substantial                     
                     weight reduction.  Cast magnesium provides an increased ductility that improves                   
                     overall toughness of the door.  Moreover, certain features are integrally formed                  
                     with the frames to reduce the total number of parts and their associated                          
                     assembly time.  For instance, an accessory mount and central hinge                                







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007