Ex Parte EBELING et al - Page 2




          Appeal No. 2003-1869                                                        
          Application 09/622,092                                                      


          operating variable and a second known operating variable, the               
          method comprising the acts of:                                              
               accessing a mathematically invertible characteristic diagram           
          for motor vehicle functions stored via support points in a                  
          cartesian coordinate system in an electronic control unit, by               
          which mathematically invertible characteristic diagram an                   
          operating variable to be determined for a first motor vehicle               
          function is entered on a Z-axis of the cartesian coordinate                 
          system;                                                                     
               reverse interpolating said mathematically invertible                   
          characteristic diagram such that an operating variable allocated            
          to the Y- or X-axis becomes an operating variable to be                     
          determined for a second motor vehicle function, said operating              
          variable allocated to the Z-axis becoming one of the first or               
          second known operating variables for determining the second motor           
          vehicle function;                                                           
               wherein one and the same characteristic diagram is stored in           
          the electronic control unit for determining the operating                   
          variable for the first and second motor vehicle functions.                  
                                   THE REJECTION                                      
               Claims 3 through 5 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 102(e)             
          as being anticipated by U.S. Patent No. 6,122,577 to Mergenthaler           
          et al. (Mergenthaler).                                                      
               Attention is directed to the main and reply briefs (Paper              
          Nos. 16 and 19) and to the final rejection and answer (Paper Nos.           
          13 and 17) for the respective positions of the appellants and the           
          examiner regarding the merits of this rejection.                            
                                     DISCUSSION                                       
               Mergenthaler discloses a method for monitoring sensors in a            
          motor vehicle wherein a reference variable used to perform a                



                                          2                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007