Ex Parte Ferguson - Page 4




          Appeal No. 2004-0177                                                        
          Application 09/792,574                                                      


          Reid system lacks response to the additional limitations in the             
          claim requiring an upper frame element forming a transparent                
          retention means within an outer perimeter and attachment means              
          for attaching the upper frame element to the lower support                  
          member.  Reid discloses no such corresponding structures.  To               
          supply these deficiencies, the examiner turns to either Levin or            
          Mitchell.                                                                   
               Levin discloses an arrangement for displaying a photograph             
          or the like on a garment such as a T-shirt.  The arrangement                
          includes a transparent plastic window 2, a hook-and-loop fastener           
          3 affixed to the perimeter of the window, a complementary hook-             
          and-loop fastener 4 affixed to the surface 5 of the T-shirt, and            
          a photograph, paper or card 6 bearing indicia 7 sized to be                 
          sandwiched and releasably held between the T-shirt and the window           
          within the boundaries of the hook-and-loop fasteners.                       
               Mitchell discloses an apparatus for attaching decorative               
          patches to an article of clothing.  Figure 12 illustrates an                
          embodiment wherein the apparatus 10 comprises a patch 12, a strip           
          of material 40 having a clear cover 42, and hook-and-loop                   
          fasteners 26, 28, on the rear surfaces of the patch and strip of            
          material and on the facing surface of the article of clothing               



                                          4                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007