Ex Parte BOESJES - Page 4




          Appeal No. 2003-0108                                                        
          Application No. 09/123,778                                                  


               The examiner contends (answer, page 8) that the entries in             
          the configuration file in Chen (column 13, lines 39 through 42)             
          “are analogous to the ‘inventory of digitally transferable                  
          goods’” in the claimed storage and distribution region.                     
               Chen clearly explains (column 3, lines 39 through 44) that             
          the configuration files 250 and 350 are for “storing                        
          specifications on accessing the information that is available               
          through the information distribution system from the plurality of           
          information suppliers 10, 20, 30.”  Chen further explains (column           
          10, lines 17 through 23) that “[r]egardless of whether the                  
          configuration files 250, 350 reside locally in the memory of                
          customer terminal 50, or are stored centrally in a central                  
          catalog system 60, any further processing requires interaction              
          between the customer terminal 50 and the supplier terminal 15,              
          25, 35 of the information supplier 10, 20, 30 that provides the             
          selected information item.”  In other words, “the supplier                  
          terminal 15 will transmit the selected information item to                  
          customer terminal 50” (column 12, lines 2 through 4).  Thus, the            
          referenced portion of Chen1 is directed to the cataloging of                

               1 We note in passing that the admitted prior art in Chen               
          (column 1, lines 32 through 55) discloses a computerized bulletin           
          board system (BBS) that includes a listing of information as well           
                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007