Ex Parte PITTARELLI - Page 5




              Appeal No. 2003-0813                                                                                     
              Application No. 08/771,885                                                                               


              the examiner, that appellant also needs to download information which is not available                   
              in local memory, from a centralized server.  Once the application program, in Ahlin and                  
              Kawan, is downloaded, the required information is now in local memory and the                            
              configuration and interface information in the references is now stored in a locally                     
              accessible associated memory “without accessing said centralized server,” as claimed.                    
              It appears to us that interpretation of the instant claim language is a matter of “when”                 
              one is looking at the status of the system.  If the required information is already located              
              at the local memory, then that information is accessible “without accessing said                         
              centralized server.”  However, if the information is not available at the local memory,                  
              then the required information must be downloaded from the centralized server.  For                       
              example, reference is made to column 7, lines 23-50, of Ahlin, wherein there is a                        
              description of a host computer that downloads a series of application program pages to                   
              a home terminal.  Once the home terminal has the program, the program is operated                        
              from the home terminal and it is no longer necessary to download the program.                            
                     Appellant further argues that the limitation of a “wide area communications                       
              network” distinguishes over the applied references.  In particular, appellant argues that                
              since Kawan indicates that the telephone-computer therein delivers services “through                     
              an ordinary telephone instrument via conventional telephone lines...” (abstract), such                   





                                                          5                                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007