Ex Parte Roth - Page 11




                 Appeal No. 2003-1614                                                                                 Page 11                     
                 Application No. 09/817,692                                                                                                       


                 each download took place, is also obtained, and used later."  Col. 7, ll. 51-56                                                  
                 (emphasis added.)                                                                                                                


                         Figure 6 of Barrett, which the examiner also cites, depicts "a simplified example                                        
                 of a user interface showing information displayed in accordance with the invention. . . ."                                       
                 Col. 6, ll. 10-11.  Although the user interface displays a list of URLs, we see no                                               
                 evidence therein that the URLs are arranged based at least in part upon a particular                                             
                 time during the day.  To the contrary, the URLs are arranged "based on the decreasing                                            
                 number of past occurrences."  Col. 8, l. 61.                                                                                     


                         For its part, the second-to-last passage cited by the examiner identifies Web                                            
                 pages based on frequency of selection or recency of selection rather than on time-of-                                            
                 day.  Specifically, "a Web page likely to be selected is identified.  This may be done by                                        
                 taking the most frequently occurring page, or by other suitable means such as                                                    
                 weighting past occurrences according to how recently they took place."  Col. 7, ll. 5-8                                          
                 (emphases added).                                                                                                                


                         The last passage cited by the examiner describes "an 'Instant Hot List.'"  Col. 10,                                      
                 ll. 54-55.  "This is a list of previously visited pages, comparable to the conventional 'hot                                     
                 list' such as IBM's Quick List, but which includes a ranking based on a suitable factor,                                         







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007