Ex Parte Sullivan - Page 8




               Appeal No. 2004-0242                                                                          Page 8                  
               Application No. 09/873,594                                                                                            


                       ounces by varying the thickness of the inner layer or ply 14 and the outer cover                              
                       layer or ply 16 and secure desired "feel" and playing characteristics.                                        


               Teachings of Wu                                                                                                       
                       Wu's invention relates to golf balls and more particularly to polyurethane covered                            
               golf balls made from a polyurethane composition of a polyurethane prepolymer cured                                    
               with a slow-reacting curing agent selected from the group of slow-reacting polyamine                                  
               curing agents and difunctional glycols.  Wu states (column 1, lines 11-14) that such a                                
               golf ball has improved resiliency and shear resistance over golf balls made from                                      
               conventional polyurethane formulations.  Wu teaches (column 1, line 15, to column 2,                                  
               line 44) that:                                                                                                        
                               Conventionally, golf balls are made by molding a cover about a core that                              
                       is either a solid one-piece core or a wound core made by winding thin elastic                                 
                       thread about a center. The center is either a solid mass or a liquid-filled envelope                          
                       which has been frozen prior to winding the thread therearound. Golf balls made                                
                       from a solid core are referred to conventionally as two-piece balls while those                               
                       with wound cores are referred to as three-piece balls. Attempts have been made                                
                       to make a one-piece golf ball, i.e. a solid homogeneous golf ball; however, to                                
                       date no commercially acceptable one-piece golf ball has been made.                                            
                               Balata had been used as the primary material for covers of golf balls until                           
                       the 1960's when SURLYNŽ, an ionomeric resin made by E.I. dupont de                                            
                       Nemours & Co., was introduced to the golf industry. SURLYNŽ costs less than                                   
                       balata and has a better cut resistance than balata. At the present time,                                      
                       SURLYNŽ is used as the primary source of cover stock for two-piece golf balls.                                
                       The problem with SURLYNŽ-covered golf balls, however, is that they lack the                                   
                       "click" and "feel" which golfers had become accustomed to with balata. "Click" is                             
                       the sound made when the ball is hit by a golf club while "feel" is the overall                                
                       sensation imparted to the golfer when the ball is hit.                                                        








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007