Ex Parte GOSHEY et al - Page 7



          Appeal No. 2004-0933                                                        
          Application 09/256,680                                                      
          in the order provided by the linked list (EA5).  The examiner               
          finds that upon receiving a request "for an application or a                
          filename, a reset stamp identifier module (260) uses a linked               
          list of reset stamps to retrieve all backup files including all             
          components of said requested application" (EA5).  The examiner              
          refers to column 8, lines 20-36 (EA5).                                      
               Appellants reply that it is not understood on what basis the           
          examiner asserts that building a linked list of reset stamps in             
          conjunction with the file list builder module and the linked list           
          identifier module leads to the creation of a linked list of                 
          application components installed in a computer (RBr4).                      
               We find that Pongracz does not disclose "creating a linked             
          list of application components installed on the computer system."           
          Pongracz discloses creating a list of backup files, not a list of           
          application components installed on the computer system.                    
          Moreover, the list is not a linked list.  The portion of Pongracz           
          originally cited for a linked list does not mention a linked list           
          and the examiner changes the portion relied on in the answer.               
          The only linked list mentioned in Pongracz is the linked list of            
          reset stamps at column 3, lines 17-19, and column 8, lines 25-28.           
          A reset stamp is a unique identifier created by coupling the                
          current value of the transaction counter with the integer                   

                                        - 7 -7                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007