Ex Parte ROSE - Page 6


         Appeal No. 2004-1046                                                       
         Application No. 09/354,203                                                 

              We are not persuaded that the appellant has met his burden            
         of proving long-felt need and failure of others.  As evidence,             
         the appellant relies on the following:                                     
              1. declaration of Mack Rose filed Aug. 22, 2000, to which             
                   were attached: (a) a letter from Don Martine of                  
                   Martine Drywall of Jan. 21, 2000 (Exhibit A); (b) Nick           
                   Moretti, A Step in the Right Direction, WALLS &                  
                   CEILINGS (2000) (Exhibit B); (c) E-mail from John                
                   Friley to “Mack” at mack@macksstep.com (June 29,                 
                   2000)(Exhibit C); (d) a letter from Pat Carrasco of              
                   Rocker Chronicles to Mack’s Step Inc. (Exhibit D); a             
                   draft article authored by Pat Carrasco (Exhibit E);              
                   (f) E-mail from Joe Wheeler of The Construction Zone             
                   to “Mack” at mack@macksstep.com (June 17,                        
                   2000)(Exhibit F); and (g) Mack’s Step Inc. “Sales by             
                   Item Detail” (Jan. 1 through Aug.10, 2000)(Exhibit G);           
              2. declaration of Ralph J. Adkins filed Aug. 22, 2000;                
              3. declaration of Maxx Belton filed Aug. 22, 2000; and                
              4. supplemental declaration of Mack Rose filed Dec. 26,               
                   2000, to which was attached a letter from Gary Bowman            
                   of Bowman Master Craftsmen to Mack’s Step (Exhibit H).           
              There can be no question that the appellant’s relied upon             
         evidence suggests that certain individuals considered a specific           

                                         6                                          


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007