Ex Parte DJUPSJOBACKA et al - Page 6



                Appeal No. 2004-1309                                                                           
                Application No.  09/410,978                                                                    

                “function” is a “factor related to or dependent upon other factors”2.  Thus, we find           
                that the claimed profile is a factor upon which the itinerary of physical locations is         
                dependent.                                                                                     
                      While we concur with the Examiner’s statement on page 15 of the brief,                   
                that both Bull and DeLorme teach a profile, we do not find that the profile taught             
                is a factor upon which the itinerary of physical locations is dependent.  Bull                 
                teaches that the profiles are used to narrow the information retrieval, see page 5             
                lines 28 to 30.  DeLorme teaches that the profiles are to reduce repetitive data               
                entry; all of the profiles disclosed are directed to the selection of goods or                 
                services (see Column 61, lines 5-26).   However, as stated surpa, the claimed                  
                invention includes two types of information to be provided to the user and the                 
                claimed user profiles are a factor upon which the itinerary of physical locations is           
















                                                                                                               
                2 Definition from the Random House College Dictionary, Revised Edition, 1982.                  

                                                      6                                                        



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007