Ex Parte CALDWELL et al - Page 7



          Appeal No.  2004-1597                                                        
          Application No.  09/383,889                                                  
          and arranging the data in a particular relational manner.3  Other            
          disclosed embodiments describe a different and particular schema             
          such as considering the entropy of the data (page 5) and row                 
          major order (page 7), which more specifically define how the data            
          is “partitioned” and “reordered.”                                            
               Therefore, we remain unconvinced by Appellants that “schema”            
          defines anything more than a generic name for compression                    
          technique that involves some form of dividing and arranging the              
          data.  Attributing to “schema” the full range of its ordinary                
          meaning as understood by skilled artisan and without importing               
          limitations from the specification into the claim, the step of               
          “transforming the data in accordance with a schema” reads on the             
          step of dividing the uncompressed, unmodified codes into cache               
          line blocks of Breternitz.  Additionally, even if some form of               
          partitioning and reordering are required in a “schema,” the                  
          divided code is indeed, partitioned and reordered into blocks,               
          which are later compressed.  Even claim 2, which requires that               

               3  Schema is defined as “a description of a database to the database    
          management system (DBMS), generated using the data definition language       
          provided by the DBMS....Regardless of context, however, a schema defines a   
          particular view of some aspect of the database ....”  Computer Dictionary,   
          Microsoft Press, Second Edition, 1994.                                       
               Schema is also defined as “the structure of a database system, described
          in a formal language supported by the database management system (DBMS).  In a
          relational database, the schema defines the tables, the fields in each table,
          and the relationships between fields and tables.”  Webopedia online          
          encyclopedia, (http://webopedia.com), as modified June 21, 2002.             
               Copies of these two definitions accompany this decision.                
                                          7                                            




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007