Appeal No. 2004-2118 Page 2 Application 09/329,502 employed including “an initial alkylation of the aromatic substrate followed by an intermediate recovery operation and then transalkylation” (specification, page 2). Appellants acknowledge that “[i]n both alkylation and transalkylation, whether conducted in the liquid phase or in the vapor phase, it is a conventional practice to employ catalysts in the reactors comprising shape-selective molecular sieves” that “. . . may be the same or different . . . .” Id. Also, appellants acknowledge that, while not universal, “it is often the practice to employ a relatively small to intermediate pore size molecular sieve such as ZSM-5, ZSM-11, or silicalite in the alkylation reactor and follow this with a molecular sieve having a somewhat larger pore size, such as zeolite-Y . . . .” (appellants’ specification, page 3, first full paragraph). Appellants use a high porosity zeolite-Y molecular sieve1 having a specified silica/alumina ratio, a specified pore size and a specified surface area as a catalyst in the transalkylation 1 Appellants refer to a high porosity zeolite-Y as one that possesses a surface area less than 500 m2/g (specification, page 9, lines 2-5). At page 15 of the specification, it is stated that “[t]he foregoing catalyst characteristics are for the zeolite-Y catalyst as it exists in the crystallite form.”Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007