Barton et al or Fischhoff et al v. Adang et al. - Page 83




          Interference 103,781                                                        

          comprehensive records . . . of what you do on a day-in/day-out              
          basis” (MR 0466, Delaware I trial transcript, p. 1089, l. 9-10),            
          Fischhoff answered (emphasis added):                                        
               A.  Yes.  Certainly for our laboratory work we do.                     
               Q.  Why do you do that?                                                
               A.  Well, it’s important for scientists to document their              
               work.  We do a lot of experiments, not all of which work,              
               and you have to know where you’ve been, what the results               
               have been to figure out where you’re going to move next                
               and the laboratory notebook is the place to do it.                     
          (Id.).                                                                      
               Second, as its case-in-chief for priority of invention,                
          Adang “alleges . . . that the invention as defined by Count 2 was           
          first conceived by M. Adang and E. Murray on November 6, 1985[,]            
          . . .” and “alleges to have exercised reasonable diligence during           
          the critical period” (AB 43, para. 1a) just prior to October 30,            
          1986, to its constructive reduction to practice on September 9,             
          1988 (AB 44, first full para.).  Accordingly, Adang’s allegation            
          that it conceived of the invention of Count 2 before Fischhoff’s            
          earliest conception date and evidence in support thereof is no              
          less persuasive and Adang’s burden to show that it exercised                
          reasonable diligence during the critical period is reduced by               
          our finding that Fischhoff first conceived of the invention of              
          Count 2 no later than December 12, 1986.                                    


                                        -83-                                          





Page:  Previous  76  77  78  79  80  81  82  83  84  85  86  87  88  89  90  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007