Appeal No. 2004-0779 Application No. 09/790,185 Page 8 In a first configuration of an apparatus for recording and reproducing optical disks whereon information can be recorded, erased and reproduced. [A] recording layer 303 of a phase-changeable material that can reversibly change between a crystal phase and an amorphous phase is formed on top of the dielectric layer 302. When an optical disk has a recording layer consisting of a thin film that can be reversibly changed between these two optically detectable states, it can be used as a high-density rewritable exchangeable medium, for example a DVD-RAM. From this disclosure of Oshima, we find a suggestion that the recording layer may be rewritable. However, from the disclosure of Oshima (col. 4, line 63 through col. 5, line 2) that: [T]he write-once information is recorded by partially removing the reflective layer. It is preferable that in the optical disk according to the third configuration, the main information and the write-once information are recorded by partially changing a reflection coefficient of a reflective layer. From this disclosure of Oshima that the write-once information is recorded by partially removing the reflective layer, we find that in Oshima, the recording layer is "write-only" and is not rewritable. However, even assuming arguendo that we are incorrect in our understanding of the disclosure of Oshima, and Oshima teaches a rewritable recording layer, claim 1 is still notPage: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007