Ex Parte EDWARDS et al - Page 6




             Appeal No. 2004-1201                                                                                     
             Application No. 09/051,118                                                                               

             across all stated rejections of the claims on appeal admits that Dolan does                              
             not specifically teach two key features recited in each claim on appeal, that                            
             of assigning a different identifier to a link and selecting an identifier from                           
             among different presented identifiers assigned to the link presented for                                 
             selection.  We agree with appellants’ views expressed initially at pages 9                               
             and 10 of the principal brief on appeal that Kogan actually fails to teach or                            
             suggest that which is asserted by the examiner to make up for the                                        
             deficiencies of Dolan.                                                                                   
                    Because we essentially agree with appellants’ views at pages 9 and                                
             10 of the principal brief on appeal, we reproduce them here:                                             
             Kogan discloses selecting an “anchor” using user command.  Kogan                                         
             states that the exact nature of the command is not relevant and will most                                
             frequently be a pointing device such as a mouse.  (See footnote 2 in col. 8                              
             of Kogan).  Appellant submits that Kogan thus fails to remedy Dolan’s                                    
             deficiency of failing to teach a “command-based interface” for inputting                                 
             identifiers.  One of ordinary skill in the art would not have been even                                  
             motivated to look at Kogan for a teaching as to what might useful in                                     








                                                         -6-                                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007