Ex Parte EDWARDS et al - Page 9




             Appeal No. 2004-1201                                                                                     
             Application No. 09/051,118                                                                               

             on appeal are not met by the combination of Dolan and Kogan as asserted                                  
             by the examiner, and in view of the fact that the examiner does not assert                               
             that any other reference relied upon to reject the claims on appeal teaches                              
             or suggests these two respective key features of each independent claim                                  
             on appeal, the rejection of each independent claim and their respective                                  
             dependent claims must be reversed.  In other words, the other references                                 
             relied upon by the examiner do not make up for the deficiencies noted with                               
             respect to the combination of Dolan and Kogan.                                                           



















                                                         -9-                                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007