Ex Parte Nguyen - Page 8




                Appeal No. 2004-2267                                                                           Page 8                   
                Application No. 09/651,184                                                                                              


                row, "the server places the client on a waiting list to obtain the lock."  Id. at ll. 45-46.  "If                       
                the client is waiting for the lock for more than a predetermined period of time, the server                             
                may remove the client from the waiting list and send an error message back to the                                       
                client."  Id. at ll. 47-50.  For our part, we are unpersuaded that Nori's determining                                   
                whether a client has waited to obtain a lock for more than a predetermined period of                                    
                time teaches the claimed reviewing of time stamps corresponding to the names of data                                    
                files stored in a temporary directory to determine if a predetermined time delay has                                    
                passed.                                                                                                                 


                        The second passage of the reference relied on by the examiner discloses that                                    
                "[t]o ensure that a particular client sees a consistent view of the database, the server                                
                sends to the client data from a particular 'snapshot' of the database.  A snapshot is like                              
                a timestamp.  A snapshot of the database reflects all changes committed to the                                          
                database as of a particular point in time, and no changes committed after that point in                                 
                time."  Col. 7, ll. 25-30.  "When a client reads LOB data, changes that have been made                                  
                to the LOB data must be removed from the LOB data before the LOB data is supplied to                                    
                the client if the changes were made after the snapshot time being used by the client."                                  
                Id. at ll. 30-34.  For our part, we are unpersuaded that Nori's removing of changes made                                
                to LOB data after the snapshot time being used by a client, teaches the claimed                                         
                reviewing time stamps corresponding to the names of data files stored in a temporary                                    








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007