Ex Parte MARTIN et al - Page 8




                Appeal No. 2005-0004                                                                                                           
                Application No. 09/135,230                                                                                                     

                         On page 7 of the brief, appellants argue that:                                                                        
                                 Nothing in Little et al. teaches or suggests that connection information                                      
                         pertaining to a particular network address to be accessed is utilized in making a                                     
                         network connection between a network browser and a server machine                                                     
                         associated with the particular network address.                                                                       
                         We are not convinced as the examiner relies upon Gauvin to teach retrieving                                           
                access information.  As stated supra we find that Gauvin teaches the connection                                                
                information is in a database.  A database is defined as “any aggregation of data a file                                        
                consisting of a number of records (or tables), each of which is constructed of fields                                          
                (columns) of a particular type, together with a collection of operations that facilitate                                       
                searching, sorting, recombination, and similar activities.”3  Thus, we find that Gauvin                                        
                teaches the information as claimed and that the information is described generically as                                        
                in a database, but we find that Gauvin is silent as to the data structure used in the                                          
                database and as such does not teach a table indexed by based upon network address.                                             
                Little teaches a computer system where a look up table (a form of a database) is used                                          
                to determine to which host, of a plurality of hosts, a particular packet of data is to be                                      
                sent. (Little, column 6, lines 18-29).  The look up table is indexed based upon MAN                                            
                number (a host identifier, type of address) to determine a hardware address (see                                               
                column 7, lines 4-9).  Thus, Little teaches that data for use in establishing network                                          
                connection should be indexed based upon address.  We find that this suggests to the                                            
                skilled artisan that the database of Gauvin should be formatted as tables indexed by                                           
                address.                                                                                                                       

                3 Definition taken from Computer Dictionary, The Comprehensive Standard For Business,                                          
                School, Library and Home, Microsoft Press, 1991.                                                                               
                                                                     -8-                                                                       



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007