Ex Parte Wohlrab - Page 4



          Appeal No. 2005-0322                                                        
          Application No. 10/431,268                                                  

          element and the tie bar has a number of recesses disposed in                
          axial spaced-apart relationship and engageable by the projections           
          to establish a form-fitting connection.  As conceded by the                 
          examiner (see page 3 in the answer), however, each of these                 
          references fails to respond to the limitation in claim 1                    
          requiring the projections and recesses to be pressed together               
          when exposed to a tensile stress and interlock at an axial                  
          clearance which increases along the engagement zone in axial                
          direction corresponding to the tensile stress of the tie bar.  To           
          address these deficiencies, the examiner turns to either Holbrook           
          or Ing.                                                                     
               Holbrook and Ing disclose injection molding machines similar           
          in many respects to those disclosed by Mailliet, Choi, Arend and            
          Hammon.  The Holbrook and Ing machines differ from the Mailliet,            
          Choi, Arend and Hammon machines, however, in that the cooperating           
          surfaces of their tie bars (Holbrook’s columns 14 and Ing’s tie             
          bars 16) and securing elements (Holbrook’s inner clamp sleeve 80            
          and Ing’s gripper sleeve 98) are smooth and without axially                 
          spaced apart projections or recesses.  The Holbrook and Ing                 
          securing elements comprise walls of fluid expansible chambers.              


                                          4                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007