Ex Parte Sullivan - Page 14




                Appeal No. 2005-0806                                                                             Page 14                    
                Application No. 10/179,812                                                                                                  



                they have a deficiency as a golf ball cover material in that they tend to be hard. This                                     
                invention is concerned with a mixture of a hard ionomer with a soft ionomer in                                              
                order to produce a golf ball cover composition wherein the cover is softer than the prior                                   
                art ionomer covers.  Sullivan states that a golf ball covered in accordance with his                                        
                invention is durable and a skilled golfer can impart back spin to the ball in play.                                         


                        Sullivan teaches that (1) for over a decade the trade attempted to solve the                                        
                problem associated with Surlyn® covered golf balls by the blending of hard Surlyn® with                                     
                a soft Surlyn®; (2) until his invention, the blending of a hard Surlyn® and a soft Surlyn®                                  
                was totally unsatisfactory in the production of a commercially viable golf ball; and (3) in                                 
                accordance with his invention, it has been found that when a hard Surlyn®  or a mixture                                     
                of hard Surlyn®  resins are blended with a soft Surlyn®  which is a terpolymer of                                           
                methacrylic acid and iso- or n-butylacrylate partially neutralized with a metal salt, a                                     
                superior golf ball cover formulation is produced.  Sullivan provides that the resulting                                     
                cover composition of his invention is intermediate in softness between a balata covered                                     
                golf ball and a hard Surlyn®  covered golf ball, to such a degree that an adequate back                                     
                spin can be imparted to the ball by a skilled golfer. Further, the resulting golf ball                                      
                exhibits a degree of cut resistance which is adequate for play and which exhibits                                           
                outstanding distance properties which is exhibited by its coefficient of restitution and/or                                 
                initial velocity.                                                                                                           







Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007