Ex Parte Sullivan - Page 7




             Appeal No. 2005-0806                                                          Page 7              
             Application No. 10/179,812                                                                        



             resinous material such as type 1855 Surlyn® which is a comparatively soft, low flexural           
             modulus resinous material.                                                                        


                   Horiuchi's invention relates to a golf ball having excellent impact resilience and          
             flying performance, of which the cover is formed from an ionomer resin which contains             
             an alpha, beta-ethylenic unsaturated carboxylic acid in a larger amount than                      
             conventional ionomer resins.   In the background of the invention, Horiuchi provides that         
             it is known to compose a golf ball of a core and a cover covering the core wherein the            
             ionomer resin which is used as the cover of the golf balls contain alpha, beta-ethylenic          
             unsaturated carboxylic acid in an amount of less than 15% by weight.  In the summary              
             of the invention, Horiuchi states that                                                            
                          It has been surprisingly found that a carboxyl-rich ionomer resin which              
                   contains 16 to 30% by weight of an alpha, beta-ethylenic unsaturated carboxylic             
                   acid significantly improves the properties of the golf balls, such as impact                
                   resilience and flying performance. Thus, the present invention provides a golf ball         
                   which comprises a core and a cover covering the core, wherein the cover                     
                   contains at least 20% by weight of a carboxyl-rich ionomer resin prepared by                
                   neutralizing 15 to 80 mol % of carboxylic acid groups of an olefinic copolymer              
                   containing 16 to 30% by weight of an alpha, beta-ethylenic unsaturated                      
                   carboxylic acid with monovalent or divalent metal ions.                                     
             Horiuchi then provides (column 1, lines 50-59) that                                               
                   an amount of the alpha, beta-ethylenic unsaturated carboxylic acid is limited to            
                   16 to 30% by weight, preferably 20 to 30% by weight, based on the total                     
                   monomer weight. Thus, the balance of the monomer is the alpha-olefin. If the                
                   amount of the alpha, beta-ethylenic unsaturated carboxylic acid is less than 16%            








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007