Ex Parte Laukhuf et al - Page 5




              Appeal No. 2005-0844                                                                        5               
              Application No. 10/397,807                                                                                  


                     After carefully assessing the embodiment seen in Figures 5 and 6 of McCarthy,                        
              we agree with the examiner that the electrical cord (6) seen therein passes through an                      
              opening or notch formed in the lower wall (64) of the housing which also defines the                        
              bottom wall of recessed compartment (60).  The portion of the specification of McCarthy                     
              bridging columns 5 and 6 describes the recessed compartment (60) in the following                           
              manner:                                                                                                     
                     Fig. 6 further illustrates a recessed compartment, designated by reference                           
                     numeral 60, defined at the rear end of the housing 4.  The compartment                               
                     60 is defined between upper and lower walls 62 and 64 of the housing 4,                              
                     and a recessed rear wall of the housing designated by reference numeral                              
                     66.  The compartment 60 provides a space in which the coupling element                               
                     10 of the electrical cord 6 can be connected to the housing 4 without                                
                     physically interfering with other nearby structure.  The compartment 60, as                          
                     illustrated by Fig. 6, is opened at the rear, but can be sealed as, for                              
                     example, when the unit 2 is mounted to a wall or panel, as illustrated by                            
                     Fig. 2.                                                                                              

                     Given the showing in Figure 6, and by describing the compartment (60) as                             
              “recessed” and as being “defined between upper and lower walls 62 and 64 of the                             
              housing” (emphasis added), and as being open at the back, but being capable of being                        
              sealed when the unit (2) is mounted to a wall or panel, as illustrated in Figure 2, it is                   
              clear to us that the lower housing wall (64) in McCarthy extends to the back edge of                        
              compartment (60) that is remote from wall (66) and provides a bottom wall for the                           
              recessed, sealable compartment.  Thus, of necessity, an opening or cord notch must be                       
              present in the lower wall (64) to allow placement or passage of the electrical cord (6) in                  








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007