Ex Parte Kinsman et al - Page 3




             Appeal No. 2005-1398                                                          Page 3              
             Application No. 10/202,359                                                                        


                          1.  A method for connecting at least one semiconductor                               
                          device to a substrate, comprising:                                                   
                                providing a carrier substrate with at least one                                
                          alignment device thereon, the at least one alignment device                          
                          including at least one receptacle configured to receive at                           
                          least an edge of the at least one semiconductor device; and                          
                                inserting at least the edge of the at least one                                
                          semiconductor device into the at least one receptacle with                           
                          the at least one semiconductor device oriented nonparallel to                        
                          the carrier substrate, a feature of the at least one                                 
                          semiconductor device retaining a complementary feature of                            
                          the at least one alignment device.                                                   

                   Claim 1 reads on Grabbe’s method of insertion of semiconductor device 92 into               
             connector 80 on substrate 86, as illustrated in Figures 5-7, as follows.  Grabbe                  
             discloses providing a carrier substrate 86 with at least one alignment device (connector          
             80) thereon, the alignment device including at least one receptacle (channel 64)                  
             configured to receive at least an edge of semiconductor device 92 and inserting at least          
             an edge of the semiconductor device 92 into the receptacle (channel 64) with the                  
             semiconductor device 92 oriented nonparallel to the substrate 86 (note Figures 6 and              
             7).  As illustrated in Figure 7, the contact pad 96 of the semiconductor device 92 retains        
             the spring arm 18 of the alignment device (connector 80) against surface 78 of wall 58            
             of the connector 80 by contact of the contact pad 96 against a contact surface 38 of the          
             spring arm 18.                                                                                    
                   The appellants’ argument (brief, page 7; reply brief, page 4) that Grabbe’s                 
             semiconductor device 92 lacks any feature that retains a corresponding feature of the             






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007