Ex Parte Tsen et al - Page 5



         Appeal No. 2005-1496                                                       
         Application 09/994,439                                                     

              Giese discloses a shoe bottom having a desirable combination          
         of cushioning and stability (see column 2, lines 14 through 22).           
         In general, the bottom 1 includes a relatively firm lower layer            
         2, a relatively soft upper layer 3 having an upper surface                 
         contoured to complement the shape of a wearer’s sole and, when             
         the bottom 1 is used in an athletic shoe, a rubber outsole 5               
         beneath the lower layer 2.  As shown in Figures 78 through 82,             
         the outsole 5 may take the form of a shell having an upwardly              
         extending peripheral rim for receiving the lower and upper layers          
         therein (see column 10, lines 36 though 47).  Giese explains with          
         respect to the embodiment shown in Figures 6 through 10 that such          
         a shell or cup-shaped configuration maintains the relatively soft          
         layer in the center of the shoe bottom to assist its shock                 
         absorbing function and prevents lateral deformation thereof which          
         can lead to premature failure of the layer (see column 8, lines            
         51 through 64; and column 1, line 60, through column 2, line 4).           
                                                                                   
              Campagna discloses a shoe comprising, inter alia, an upper            
         1, a rubber outer sole 7 and a foxing 9 composed of gum rubber or          
         a rubber-coated fabric vulcanized over the joint or seam between           
         the upper and outer sole (see Figure 2 and column 4, lines 20              
         through 30).                                                               


                                         5                                          


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007