Ex Parte Goerenz et al - Page 8



          Appeal No. 2005-1577                                                        
          Application No. 09/581,159                                 Page 8           

          as disclosed by Winter but rather are concerned with other types            
          of glazes and preparation methods therefore and, as such, offer             
          no particular suggestion as to how to modify the antenna                    
          structure of Winter.                                                        
               For example, Winter places no special requirements on the              
          relative location of the outer boundaries of the electro-                   
          conductive coating (212) that forms an antenna and is sealed                
          between the two glass plies using a thermoplastic interlayer.               
          See, e.g, column 4, lines 25-56 of Winter.  While Winter does               
          teach that the antenna connector (224) can be positioned along a            
          surface (214) of the glass ply (216) in order to establish a                
          direct connection with the antenna coating (212), there is no               
          specific teaching in Winter concerning how such a direct                    
          connection arrangement is to be formed for a two ply glazing,               
          although Winter does indicate that the connector (224) is                   
          relatively small when employing a direct connection as compared             
          to the size thereof when employing a capacitive coupling                    
          arrangement.                                                                
               Koontz and Tweadey, which references are not drawn to                  
          windows having antenna systems, are not particularly relevant in            
          suggesting to one of ordinary skill in the art how the antenna              
          system and connections of the glazing of Winter should be made.             





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007