Ex Parte Thompson et al - Page 7




            Appeal No.  2005-2329                                                                          
            Application No. 09/738,293                                                                     

                  best received signals mentioned as the main invention of Klein                           
                  (Klein, Abstract, col. 7, lines 34-46, and fig. 1); moreover, Klein                      
                  clearly teaches the switch control features can be modified on a                         
                  keypad of a telephone (virtual switches on a telephone, col. 17,                         
                  line 64-col. 18 line 27) to switch/change and transfer of a                              
                  conventional land-based telephone.                                                       
                  For its part, Klein clearly buttresses the teachings of prior art                        
            networks and telephone systems already discussed in Tang.  Note the                            
            corresponding showings in Figures 1 and 10 of Klein and the corresponding                      
            discussion of Figure 1 at columns 4 and 5.  These teachings here make                          
            known that prior art PBX and PABX telephone systems as well as standard                        
            analog/digital telephones and their corresponding analog/digital systems                       
            and networks may be utilized with which to embody the environment of                           
            use of Klein.  Such clearly buttress the teachings of the prior art telephone                  
            networks already discussed in Tang, but also suggest to the artisan prior                      
            art types of digital networks including DSL as well as ISDN networks well                      
            known in the public telephone environment.  Such are relied upon in part                       
            in the arguments of the examiner as to the rejection of dependent claim 48                     
            such as the integrated services digital network capabilities recited there                     
            which the examiner has shown to be admitted by appellants to be a part of                      

                                                    -7-                                                    





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007