Ex Parte Mathus et al - Page 6



          Appeal No. 2005-2350                                                        
          Application No. 10/056,352                                                  

          separately attachable carrier part 16 in figure 2b.  Note the               
          teachings at column 2, lines 30 through 36; column 2, line 50 to            
          column 3, line 9; the discussion beginning at line 10 of column             
          3; the separate discussion of the carrier part beginning at line            
          66 of column 3 through at least column 4, line 12 as well as the            
          discussion at column 6, lines 4 through 63.                                 
               Among the significant teachings in these locations is that             
          the embodiments in which a separate carrier part is actually                
          manufactured, it may be separately glued or otherwise stuck or              
          pressed onto the tubular container of the test tube itself.  It             
          also may be molded separately and then injection molded or                  
          otherwise molded into a unitary structure along with the tubular            
          nature of the test tube itself.  To the artisan, these teachings            
          would have clearly indicated a unitary structure in which there             
          is an integral bottom.  In all embodiments the integral bottom is           
          shown and taught to be a flat bottomed portion of an overall test           
          tube structure like that claimed.  Of particular note                       
          additionally is the teaching with respect to figure 7 beginning             
          at column 7, line 22 through at least line 4 of column 8.  The              
          discussion at the bottom of column 7 beginning at line 64 plainly           



                                          6                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007