Appeal No. 2005-1817 Page 2 Application No. 09/834,499 BACKGROUND The appellant's invention relates to an automatic vehicle theft protection device having a transponder that is separate from the ignition key (specification, pages 1 and 3). Claim 1 is representative of the invention, and is reproduced as follows: 1. An automatic vehicle theft prevention system for selectively enabling an ignition system of a vehicle, said ignition system being operable using an ignition key, and said system comprising: an interrogator circuit including a signal generator for generating an excitation signal and an antenna coupled to said signal generator for radiating said excitation signal and receiving a return signal; a transponder circuit separate from said ignition key for detecting said excitation signal and radiating said return signal, said transponder circuit modulating said excitation signal to produce said return signal containing an identification code for said transponder circuit; a controller in communication with said antenna for detecting said identification code in said return signal; and a relay actuated to an enable mode by said controller when said controller detects said identification code, said relay being actuated to enable said ignition system. The prior art references of record relied upon by the examiner in rejecting the appealed claims are: Weber 3,784,839 Jan. 8, 1974 Flanagan 3,864,651 Feb. 4, 1975 Hansen 4,412,267 Oct. 25, 1983 Bethards 5,040,212 Aug. 13, 1991Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007