Ex Parte Groth - Page 5



         Appeal No. 2005-2537                                                                    
         Application No. 09/921,429                                                              

         needle storage and mounting apparatus comprising, inter alia, a                         
         cylindrical body having radial cavities and a cylindrical cover.                        
         As set forth in the underlying specification, and to some extent in                     
         claims 19, 21 and 22, these features facilitate the connection of a                     
         pen needle assembly to an injection device by allowing the tool or                      
         apparatus to be grasped in one hand and rotated 360 degrees about                       
         an axis of rotation concentric with the longitudinal axis of a                          
         radial cavity while the injection device is grasped in the other                        
         hand and rotated 360 degrees.                                                           
              To overcome the admitted deficiencies of Nguyen relative to                        
         the subject matter recited in independent claims 19, 21 and 22, the                     
         examiner turns to Current.                                                              
              Current discloses “a package for retaining and dispensing                          
         sewing machine needles” (column 1, lines 6-7).  The package                             
         comprises a circular storage disc 12 and a rotatable base or cover                      
         24.  The storage disc 12 includes a plurality of radial and                             
         circumferential walls 16 and 20 which define a plurality of needle                      
         storage compartments 18 open at their tops and radial outer ends.                       
         The rotatable base 24 consists of a circular surface 26 covering                        
         the open tops of the needle storage compartments, a downwardly                          
         extending cylindrical base wall 28 covering the open outer ends of                      
         the needle storage compartments, and a dispensing slot 34 in the                        
                                        5                                                        











Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007