Appeal No. 2006-0045 Application No. 10/190,473 The invention relates to “a constructional form of a ball-end pin with a plastic flange to be applied in ball joints of the steering and suspension systems of automotive vehicles” (specification, page 1). Representative claims 1 and 12 read as follows: 1. A ball joint assembly employed in ball joints of the steering and suspension systems of vehicles, comprising a ball-end pin and a separate plastic flange formed to receive a protection cover, wherein the flange is made of injected plastic material and has a conical central orifice with at least one of longitudinally-extending protrusions and grooves, wherein the ball-end pin is shaped by a stamping process and has a conical section with longitudinally-extending grooves that eliminates the machining process, said grooves being formed during the stamping process to mate with said longitudinally-extending protrusions. 12. A ball joint assembly employed in ball joints of the steering and suspension systems of vehicles, comprising a ball-end pin member having a spherical ball portion and a pin portion extending from the ball portion; a substantially rigid flange member matingly disposed on said pin portion, said flange member having a conical central orifice; and a resilient boot member extending from said flange member to a housing encapsulating said spherical ball portion, wherein said pin portion has a conical section, said conical section of said pin portion and said central orifice of said flange member being formed with matching longitudinally-extending grooves and protrusions to mate said flange member with said pin portion. THE PRIOR ART The references relied on by the examiner to support the final rejection are: Templeton 3,248,955 May 03, 1966 Buhl et al. (Buhl) 5,312,200 May 17, 1994 2Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007