Ex Parte Ryu et al - Page 5



         Appeal No. 2006-0126                                                       
         Application No. 10/140,619                                                 
         (brief, pages 8-9; reply brief, page 11).  Kojima ‘546 prevents            
         bubbling by using heat in addition to ultraviolet rays (¶¶ 0028,           
         0041 and 0064).  Regardless, the prevention of bubbles in                  
         Kojima ‘919 pertains to curing optical fiber coatings (¶¶ 0241,            
         0246 and 0247).  Slanting the ultraviolet rays in alignment with           
         the inclined adhesive used to join the prior art planar lightwave          
         circuit chip and optical-fiber block would have been prima facie           
         obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art as discussed above.            
              Kojima ‘546 discloses that the ultraviolet ray intensity is           
         detected by a photodetector (5) to control the ultraviolet ray             
         output to the level suitable for curing the particular adhesive so         
         that stable curing characteristics of the adhesive are obtained            
         (¶ 0024).                                                                  
              The appellants argue that Kojima ‘546 does not disclose or            
         suggest an optical sensor for measuring a power change or an               
         optical power meter for displaying the power change (brief,                
         pages 11-13; reply brief, pages 11-13).  The Kojima ‘546 disclosure        
         that the ultraviolet light output is controlled based on the               
         ultraviolet light intensity detected by a photodetector (¶ 0024)           
         would have fairly suggested, to one of ordinary skill in the art,          
         using a photodetector which measures the change in ultraviolet             
         light intensity on which the control of that ultraviolet light             

                                         5                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007