Ex Parte Himebaugh - Page 6



         Appeal No. 2006-0165                                                       
         Application 10/292,721                                                     
                                                                                   
              The appellant argues that Suarez does not disclose turning            
         address information into a mapping solution but, rather,                   
         calculates criteria parameters for limiting receipt of assignment          
         messages by drivers (brief, page 12).                                      
              Suarez discloses that the wireless communication device               
         preferably uses a navigation program to calculate whether the              
         vehicle meets the criteria parameters by being within a specified          
         driving distance or driving time of the assignment, and that               
         program takes traffic conditions into account (col. 5, line 7 -            
         col. 6, line 31; col. 11, line 57 - col. 12, line 38).  That               
         disclosure at least would have fairly suggested, to one of                 
         ordinary skill in the art, processing the assignment address and           
         vehicle location into a mapping solution in order to determine,            
         taking into account traffic conditions, the driving distance or            
         driving time.  Suarez would have fairly suggested, to one of               
         ordinary skill in the art, displaying the mapping solution to the          
         driver when the criteria parameters are met to provide the driver          
         with the shortest or quickest route from the vehicle’s location            
         to the assignment address.                                                 




                                         6                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007