Ex Parte Chickles et al - Page 2




            Appeal No. 2006-0361                                                                      
            Application 09/752,654                                                                    

                  Representative claim 73 is reproduced below:                                        
                  73.  A computer-implemented method for navigating among a                           
            hierarchy of palette windows in a graphical user interface                                
            displayed on a computer system, wherein the computer system                               
            includes a display, the method comprising:                                                
                  displaying on the display a first palette window from the                           
            hierarchy of palette windows, wherein one or more of the palette                          
            windows in the hierarchy comprise palette items that are                                  
            selectable by a user, wherein each of the palette items is                                
            selectable by the user to include functionality in a program                              
            being created or modified, wherein one or more of the palette                             
            windows comprise a palette window selection item, wherein the                             
            palette window selection item is selectable by the user to                                
            display a second palette window from the hierarchy of palette                             
            windows, and wherein the first palette window includes one or                             
            more navigation items displayed on the first palette window for                           
            navigating among the hierarchy of palette windows;                                        
                  receiving user input selecting a navigation item displayed                          
            on the first palette window;                                                              
                  closing the first palette window in response to said                                
            receiving user input selecting the navigation item; and                                   
                  displaying at least one of a parent palette window or a                             
            child palette window in relation to the first palette window in                           
            the hierarchy of palette windows in response to said user input                           
            selecting the navigation item.                                                            
                  The following references are relied on by the examiner:                             
                  Filepp et al. (Filepp)       5,758,072         May 26, 1998                         

                  Appellant’s Admitted Prior Art (hereinafter “AAPA”), pages                          
                  1-3 and Figures 4A, 4B and 4C.                                                      
                  Gavron et al. “How to Use Microsoft Windows NT 4                                    
                  Workstation”, 1996, pages 7, 40-41.                                                 
                  All claims on appeal stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103.                          
            As to claims 73 through 76, 78 through 80, 82 through 84, 86, 87,                         
            95 through 101, 103 through 113, 117 through 120, 122, 124, 128                           
            through 140, 143, 144, 146, 149, 151 and 153 through 158, the                             


                                                  2                                                   



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007