Ex Parte YAVATKAR et al - Page 5




              Appeal No. 2006-0384                                                                    Παγε 5                                         
              Application No. 09/041,979                                                                                                             


              We agree.  The system disclosed by Drake does ensure adequate QOS for each                                                             
              represented data stream.  In addition, the attributes of Drake are used for determining                                                
              bandwidth control for a particular data stream having a unique ID to the extent that a                                                 
              determination is made as to whether the components of the selected path satisfy the                                                    
              QOS values for a multimedia transmission (col. 2, lines 36-41).  Further, Drake                                                        
              discloses that bandwidth management can also be called QOS management (col. 1,                                                         
              lines 55-57).  However, in Drake, the overall function of allocator 20 is to is to receive                                             
              the QOS request from source station 10, examine the resources of LAN 17 and                                                            
              determine if a path exists between the source station 10 and target station 29 which                                                   
              satisfies the QOS (col. 2, lines 50-55).                                                                                               
                      From our review of Drake, we find that the reference to the desired multimedia                                                 
              transmission is a reference to the media stream for the multi-media call.  Drake does                                                  
              not conduct the multimedia call by using multiple-media streams for the call, as does                                                  
              appellants (specification, page 6).  Nor does Drake allocate the reserved call level                                                   
              bandwidth to individual media streams of the multi-media call, as does appellants                                                      
              (specification, page 8).       Accordingly, while we agree with the examiner (answer,                                                  
              page 8) that in Drake, an individual data stream among existing data streams in the                                                    
              transmission path requests a new bandwidth allocation (such as when changing from a                                                    
              one way client/server cal to a two-way client/client call), and that QOS is implemented                                                
              on the individual data stream after examining and identifying the Stream ID, Drake does                                                

















Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007