Ex Parte Goldenberg - Page 2


                Appeal No. 2006-0656                                                                                  Page 2                    
                Application No. 10/086,637                                                                                                      

                bispecific antibody fragment with a molecular weight of 85,000 daltons or less (such as                                         
                a divalent single chain (sFv)2 or (sFv’)2 fragment), which has a first binding site specific                                    
                for an antigen associated with the lesion, and a second binding site specific for a                                             
                bivalent labeled hapten.  Id., page 26.                                                                                         
                         According to appellant, a bispecific antibody fragment with a molecular weight of                                      
                85,000 daltons or less is “critical” (Appeal Brief, page 10) to the claimed invention                                           
                because an antibody fragment of this size is small enough to be “cleared quickly and                                            
                naturally through the kidneys . . . so that targeting [and detection] can be effected within                                    
                48 hours” (Specification, pages 4-5) with minimal background interference (id., page 2).                                        
                Fab and Fab’ fragments (about 50,000 and 55,000 daltons, respectively) are small                                                
                enough to be cleared rapidly, but are unsuitable for the claimed method because they                                            
                are monovalent, and cannot bind both antigen and labeled hapten (id., page 26).  On                                             
                the other hand, F(ab)2 or F(ab’)2 fragments (about 110,000 daltons for IgG), although                                           
                divalent, are “too large to be filtered through the glomerular basal membrane[,] . . . must                                     
                be catabolized elsewhere” first, and take much longer to clear, “unduly delay[ing] other                                        
                procedures” (id.).                                                                                                              
                                                                The Claims                                                                      
                         Claims 183-193, 196 and 197 are pending and the subject of appeal.  Claims                                             
                99-182, 194, 195 and 198-201 are also pending, but have been withdrawn from                                                     
                consideration.  Claim 183 is representative of the subject matter on appeal:                                                    
                         183.  A method of close-range detection of lesions during an operative,                                                
                endoscopic, laparoscopic, intravascular catheter, or surgical procedure, wherein the                                            
                method comprises:                                                                                                               







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007