Ex Parte Pricer et al - Page 7




         Appeal No. 2006-1055                                                       
         Application No. 09/752,355                                                 
                                                                                   
         particular user and a corresponding single session of that user            
         (“Based on a unique identifier, such as an IP number or session            
         id and a timestamp, the visitor identification module 230                  
         determines which visitor record in the database 300 will need to           
         be updated”).                                                              
              As indicated by the examiner, it is the claimed feature of            
         the servers, and the execution of the database query being                 
         “across plural parallel processing modules” which is absent from           
         Muret.                                                                     
              But the examiner has identified the teaching of Tsuchida at           
         column 2, line 54 through column 3, line 18 suggesting parallel            
         processing in a database for the advantage of quicker processing.          
         With this teaching in mind, the examiner, reasonably in our view,          
         finds that the artisan would have been led to employing plural             
         parallel processing modules in Muret to speed up the processing            
         of that system.                                                            
              Thus, the examiner has identified a deficiency of the prior           
         art system of Muret and has shown the deficiency to be taught in           
         Tsuchida, along with a reason for the artisan to have been led to          









                                         7                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007