Ex Parte Whiteside - Page 4

         Appeal Number: 2006-1059                                                   
         Application Number: 09/780,603                                             
                                                                                   
         Miles teaches a foldable mechanic’s creeper having the                     
         basic structure set forth in claim 1 on appeal including a                 
         plurality of casters (8-11) affixed to the frame of the creeper,           
         with each of said casters including a wheel.  However, as                  
         recognized by the examiner, Miles does not disclose wheels of              
         the particular configuration claimed or formed of a material               
         having a hardness level like that set forth in the claims on               
         appeal.                                                                    

         Bonzer addresses a shock resistant caster for use in                       
         moving highly sensitive pieces of equipment, such as a delicate            
         computer or other similar electronic or electrical device                  
         (col. 1, lines 34-39).  Each of the casters in Bonzer includes             
         a cushioning block (19) that resists deflection of the movable             
         wheel carrying part (17) and a wheel (18) for engaging a floor             
         surface (12).  As can be seen in Figure 2, the wheel (18) has an           
         annular peripheral tire portion (69) formed of a resiliently               
         deformable elastomeric material, e.g., neoprene rubber, and an             
         inner core portion (80) formed of a rigid material containing              
         and bonded to a rigid tubular bearing element (45).  See column            
         3, lines 47-53 of Bonzer.  In column 5, lines 15-17, it is noted           
         that the material of the cushioning block (19) is desirably                
         “substantially harder than the material of portion 69 of the               

                                         4                                          


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007