Ex Parte Hogan - Page 5


              Appeal No. 2006-1517                                                                   Page 5                 
              Application No. 09/976,423                                                                                    

                     In addition, the passage stating that the reagents “generate a genomic profile for                     
              use in selecting a perioperative course of action for said subject,” merely recites the                       
              intended outcome of using the regents.  The specification defines “genomic profile” as                        
              “a set of information about a given ‘subject’s’ genes (e.g., the presence or absence of a                     
              specific set of mutations or ‘SNPs’).”  Page 27, lines 13-14.  Thus, the “genomic profile”                    
              recited in the claims refers simply to the data showing the presence or absence of the                        
              recited variant alleles, and reagents that are sufficient to detect alleles in at least two of                
              the recited genes are therefore, by definition, capable of generating a genomic profile.                      
                     Finally, the kit defined by claim 72 comprises “a computer program comprising                          
              instructions which direct a processor to analyze data derived from use of said reagents.”                     
                     Claim 106 is similar to claim 72 in that it requires the same reagents (which are                      
              termed “component parts” in claim 106).  As with claim 72, the claim language stating                         
              that the “subject [is] a patient scheduled for a surgical procedure that has not yet                          
              completed said surgical procedure” recites nothing more than an intended use of the                           
              claimed kit, and does not further limit the claim.  Likewise, the recitation “so as to                        
              generate a genomic profile” also does not further limit the claim, because detecting the                      
              presence or absence of alleles in at least two of the recited genes by definition                             
              generates a genomic profile.                                                                                  
                     Finally, the claim language following “so as to generate a genomic profile” recites                    
              nothing more than the intended use of the genomic profile that is to be generated by the                      
              kit, and does not further limit the claimed kit.  That is, the kit requires regents                           
              (“component parts”) sufficient to detect polymorphisms in at least two of the recited                         
              genes, thereby generating a genomic profile, but the reagents that are capable of                             





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007