Ex Parte JIANG et al - Page 13




         Appeal No. 2006-1605                                                       
         Application No. 09/470,741                                                 

         definition motion vectors in the neighborhood of blocks in which           
         to filter, following a down conversion scheme. See page 9,                 
         section 4.1, page 10, section 4.2 and page 11, section 4.3.  We            
         also find that Vetro provides adequate motivation for this                 
         combination by suggesting that the resulting filtering scheme              
         minimizes the mean square error between a reference block and a            
         block obtained through the low resolution MC to thereby perform a          
         motion compensation on macroblocks a, b, c, and d to yield h. See          
         page 4, section 2.  Next, we find that Ng complements Vetro’s              





         teachings by suggesting the use of motion vectors in a motion              
         compensation scheme following the down-sampling of HDTV                    
         compressed digital images.  We also find that Ng provides                  
         motivation for this combination by indicating that the suggested           
         approach offers the advantages of reduced memory, slightly                 
         enhanced resolution and lessened computational speed                       
         requirements. See column 6, lines 50-54.  Additionally, we find            
         that Bose further reinforces the Vetro and Ng combination through          
         its explicit teaching of a motion vector in a motion compensation          
         scheme for digital video, wherein the motion vector specifies a            
         relative vertical or horizontal distance from a reference data to          
         a macroblock.  We also find that Bose provides proper motivation           

                                         13                                         





Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007