Appeal No. 2006-1643 Παγε 6
Application No. 09/845,589
examiner turns to Monn for a teaching of cutting out images and
fixing them to a surface in a scrapbook.
Appellants' position (brief, page 8) is that there is no
teaching or suggestion in FJCP concerning making scrapbook pages.
Appellants note that claim 1 calls for the instructions and
visual images to be formed on the photographic print medium, and
that in contrast, there is no suggestion in FJCP to place the
greeting on photo stock. It is argued (id.) that a greeting on a
greeting card is not instructions for making a scrapbook page.
With respect to Monn, appellants assert that MOnn shows a
separate sheet having instructions and says nothing about
combining the instructions with the photo on the same medium,
much less a photographic medium.
Appellants further assert (id.) that claim 1 requires
allowing the user to manually cut out the series of
different characteristics of visual images from the
medium in accordance with the instructions; and
allowing the user to manually fix the cut out different
visual images on the page forming a composite image on
the page in accordance with the instructions which can
be used in the scrapbook.
It is argued to the effect that FJCP does not suggest scrapbook
pages or forming a composite image, and that Monn says and
suggests nothing about forming a scrapbook page or instructions
Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Next
Last modified: November 3, 2007