Appeal No. 2006-1643 Παγε 7
Application No. 09/845,589
for cutting out images. Appellants add that tearing of an
offending border is not teaching or suggesting anything about
cutting out the series of images.
From our review of FJCP, we find that the reference
discloses a Total Choice Collection that includes enhancements.
A configuration can include a single sheet having printed thereon
one 5x7, 3 wallets and 3 billfolds. From this disclosure, we
find that the reference teaches providing a single sheet with
three different sizes, or different characteristics, of a photo.
In addition, FJCP discloses a greeting card that includes a
portrait as well as a greeting thereon. The reference is silent
as to the substrate the photo and the greeting are on. However,
from the disclosure of a photo and a greeting on the greeting
card, we find that both the photo and the greeting are on the
photographic print medium, since whatever medium is used to print
the photo and the greeting is the photographic print medium.
Turning to the greeting, we find that the content of the
greeting is printed matter, and that the content of the greeting
does not patentably distinguish from the prior art. Whether the
printed matter is a statement such as “Announcing the Graduate”
or instructions for creating scrapbook page from the photos does
not have patentable weight. In addition, from the disclosure of
Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Next
Last modified: November 3, 2007