Ex Parte Kraffert - Page 8


                    Appeal No. 2006-1778                                                                                                
                    Application 09/776,364                                                                                              


                    even different modeled products 100 that may be conveyed along conveyance 110 in                                    
                    figure 1.   The host computer 122 provides accessibility to shared files within the                                 
                    database 130 through the shared filed directory 127 to the extent recited in the claims                             
                    on appeal.                                                                                                          
                           To embellish upon the examiner’s reasoning of combinability, it appears to us                                
                    from our study of Gartner and Fitting that the artisan would well appreciate that the                               
                    teachings of Fitting obviously would have enhanced the operability of Gartner’s                                     
                    system to make it usable within a plurality of test system environments.  Additionally,                             
                    the closing paragraph at column 7, lines 36 through 60 of Fitting teaches the distinct                              
                    advantages of the approach followed by Fitting such that when information is placed                                 
                    in the name of a file and communicated by a test system, the recipient host computer                                
                    can readily read the information based upon the name alone without having to perform                                
                    a lot of other accessing functions.  Furthermore, the showing of the accessibility of file                          
                    information by file name in Figure 2 of Gartner and its ability to access an external file                          
                    reference based upon the two parameters of the identification of the server as well as                              
                    the name of a file obviously would have been complemented and enhanced by the                                       
                    additional teachings just mentioned in Fitting with the ability to seek the                                         
                    corresponding information necessarily based upon a product identifier as combined                                   
                    with or otherwise concatenated with particularly requested data types.  The                                         







                                                                       8                                                                



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007